
Dubai Desert Classic Leader Stirs Controversy with Lucky Grandstand Shot on 18th Hole
A Scottish pro golfer sparked debate with a lucky bounce off a grandstand during the Dubai Desert Classic. Ewen Ferguson, leading after 36 holes, hit his approach shot on the par-5 18th hole that sailed over the green, struck the spectator grandstand, and bounced back to within 5 feet of the hole.
Ferguson made the eagle putt to take the tournament lead, but the fortunate bounce raised questions about intentionally using the grandstand as a backboard - a practice known as "grandstanding."
When asked about the shot, Ferguson explained: "I thought, I'm just going to go to the back and even if I have to go in the drop zone, I'm just going to splash it out...The game kicks you enough, so to get a little break is nice."
Ewen Ferguson reacts
The incident highlighted an ongoing debate in tournament golf:
- Is using permanent structures for favorable bounces within the spirit of the game?
- Should tournaments adjust pin positions to prevent such advantages?
- Are drop zones too favorable for missed shots?
The R&A provides one solution at The Open Championship by placing brutal drop zones in long grass near grandstands, making it a genuine challenge rather than a bailout option.
While some critics called the shot "devious," Ferguson wasn't alone in this strategy. Multiple players have used the grandstand similarly, suggesting it's more a tournament setup issue than player misconduct.